Consumer Reviews: Dan Sullivan’s Perfect Dog & Command Collar

Labrador standing at attention on beach

When you search online for how to train your dog you are bound to find countless different methods, obedience classes, puppy kindergarten, training aids and much more. With all the options out there it can be hard to decide what method(s) may work best for your dog.

One of the most popular training systems around is called The Perfect Dog. It was created by a man named Don Sullivan who has created the Command Collar – similar to a pinch collar though made of plastic rather than metal.

How it Works

This method is one that follows the canine psychology rather than the human-based psychology that we often impose on our furry friends. While we may think we are doing what is best for them, often times we are letting them think they rule the house.

With a combination of a unique training system and a specially designed training collar, you can earn your dog’s respect as “alpha” in no time.

The Command Collar and the Perfect Dog system work hand in hand, though the DVDs can be used in conjunction with a pinch collar if you already own one. Many dog owners have reported that the training method worked just as well with either type of collar.

The collar is meant to simulate the act of a mother dog nipping at her pup’s neck to correct his behaviors. You see, Sullivan’s approach to dog training is probably considered a little “old fashion” considering its dominance/submissive based – but it works.

Within just a few training sessions dogs start to get the idea and immediately behaviors start to change. It may not be overnight perfection, but there will clearly be an improvement after only a short time with this system.

Why it Works

German Sherpard sitting next to a boyDon Sullivan’s The Perfect Dog system works so great because it really helps to get you inside the head of your dog. Dogs do not think as we do in terms of reward for good behavior.

For us a reward is going out to dinner, going to the movies or something of that nature. For dogs, a proper reward is a love, affection, respect, and obedience. Your dog needs to know what to expect from you and he should never be bribed into anything.

According to the Perfect Dog method, the reason that treats based training methods do not work is because your dog does not see you as the alpha. Quite the opposite actually – they generally believe they are alpha since you giving up your food to them is seen as a submissive act.

With the command collar, you are able to give a quick and swift correction with the simple pull of the lead – the collar will “nip” their neck and in most cases, the bad behavior will cease. Some dogs who are more stubborn may require more than a few corrections or a harsher correction.

This action is not intended to create “fear” in your dog as some may think. Rather it is meant to be a corrective action – in the way a dog would receive it in a park setting, the way they will instinctually understand.

This will create a level of respect between you and your dog and they will do things not simply because they know they will be corrected, but because they want to please you and keep the proper order of things.

The Public Opinion

Overall the reviewers are giving this method a thumbs up for sure! There is an overwhelming number of reviews and success stories on the web showcasing just how well this method can work.

In comparison, there are only a handful of negative reviewers and most do not agree with the philosophy of this training method – preferring more contemporary and often less effective methods such as treat based training.

From the reviews, this method will work on any breed of dog of any age. People reported great success with breeds such as golden retrievers, German shepherds, Irish wolfhounds, Labradors and even pitbull terriers – as well as ages that ranged from only weeks old to seniors.

The biggest benefits of this method are that the corrections are not too painful or harmful in any way to the dog – it is simply a small pinch of the skin around the neck. Also, many pet parents were happy to see results so soon after training started.

The only downsides are that the Command Collars are made with plastic links which some have reported breaking – though this does seem to be a rare occurrence.

The Perfect Dog VS Doggy Dan Online Dog Training

a pointer dog standing to attentionOne of the most common comparisons to The Perfect Dog method is probably Doggy Dan’s Online Dog Training program. These are actually quite similar in the philosophy that goes with it. Both are there to help you realize that you need to assert yourself as the alpha in your home.

The biggest difference is that the Perfect Dog method uses a training device – the Command Collar – where Doggy Dan does not use an outside training device. His methods are all one-on-one respect and reward with affection based.

The other big difference is the fact that Doggy Dan is a totally online-based program that also includes an entire private online community. If there is ever something that you cannot find or a question you need to be answered about training your dog you can get help from Doggy Dan and the other members.

Once you join you have access to over 250 videos of Doggy Dan showing you step by step as he helps another dog owner train their dog out of a problem you yourself are probably experiencing. With the Perfect Dog system, the DVDs cover how to use to collar in each situation in a small segment.

Doggy Dan is more of an interactive program as you will have the online access to other pet parents as well as Doggy Dan himself. However, this does not make the Perfect Dog inferior as both methods have an extremely high success rate when consulting reviews.

One thing to remember is that every dog is going to be different, just as every human is a little bit different. What works wonders for one dog may not be as effective with another – the trick is to try out a few methods, be consistent with them and decide what is working and what is not.Your dog is your best friend, your fur baby and you wouldn’t trade him for anything! Then there are those days… those particular moments and triggers that just cause your dog to lose it – all your training seems to have gone out the window.

a irish stter dog looking up

I’ve been in this situation and I’m here to tell you there’s a solution – a safe, effective training collar created by Don Sullivan. I’m sure you’re skeptical – I know I was at first.

What can this guy know that we haven’t already tried? What is so special about this collar compared to other prong or choke collars? There’s no way my dog’s behavior will change that quickly.

I thought the same thing.

Until I started reading the customer reviews. This collar has shown amazing results in so many dogs, there was no denying it! If you’re looking for a safe and easy training method this is it.

What You Need to Know

The Command Collar is made from plastic and has a safety latch like a regular collar. The difference is the small plastic plates that squeeze together gently when you tug the collar. This replicates the feeling of their mother gently biting at their scruff to show she disapproved.

Instantly your dog will be brought back to that mindset and he will be respectful almost immediately. This is a way of showing you’re the alpha in the household and what you say goes.

In the training videos, Don Sullivan explains why the treating method is not a good way to train your dog. Dogs are pack animals and the subordinates give up food to the alphas.

So in essence, by asking your dog to sit and then providing a treat when he does, you are begging your dog to sit for you.

They then get the mindset that they are the ones in charge, not you – which can lead to many behavioral issues including barking, food stealing, leash pulling and more.

Using the technique with the command collar does not mean you should never treat your dog – just do not use it as a reward for anything. Your dog’s reward for a job well done should be love and affection from you! He will respect that much more than he will a treat.

The training videos that come with the collar and leads are full of training advice to help fix many (if not all) common behavioral problems. The DVDs are there to help you make the most of your training time with the collar and get the best results, the fastest possible.

The Opinion of the Masses

a brown puppy sitting on the floorThe Don Sullivan command collar has a surprisingly large number of very positive reviews by pet parents in all sorts of situations. Almost every review you read is someone praising this collar and the technique saying it was like having a brand new dog in a day.

Many users rave how their previously mischievous pups were acting like a perfectly well-behaved dog with only a couple of training sessions.

There were some complaints about it not working well with dogs who have thicker or longer fur – it doesn’t seem that the collar was able to give the small “pinch” it needed to get the dogs attention.

Even with that frustration, it still receives high marks for the technique. If your dog has thicker hair, you might try a traditional pronged collar instead and then you can continue to use Don Sullivan’s techniques with that instead and saw just about the same results.

Some pet parents do not agree with the no treating for rewards system that is suggested to be used with this training collar – however, it is an essential part of making this type of training work.

Most people seemed to use this collar to help with pulling when on a leash. Almost all of them said that it was an instant change – like walking a whole different dog – when the put the command collar on them.

I would say this is probably one of the best investments you can make when you are looking to train your dog. One of the things I find fascinating with this collar is that it is proven to work just as well in older dogs as it does for young pups.

(can’t teach an old dog new tricks? Think again!)

This is great news for anyone who has adopted a shelter dog that is in need of some serious behavioral training.

Remember the Collar is NOT Magical

a dog running on grassAs much as the reviews may make this collar appear to be a magical training tool, it is only half of the battle. The real difference in your dog’s behavior will come with the consistent use of the collar the right way.

The DVDs that come with the collar will teach you all the essentials you need to know – so make sure you follow the directions! When it comes to training your dog you need to remember you are as much a part of the learning process as your dog.

For you and your dog to be able to enjoy your lives together in peace and happiness you will never regret one of those afternoon training sessions!

Your dog will be looking at you as the alpha of the group from now on – so don’t go giving in and giving up if your dog isn’t perfect right away! It takes commitment on your end too – the collar is not a magical device that makes your dog obedient, it only aids in the process.

The goal is to get your dog to behave properly and be responsive to you all of the time, not only when they are on the leash wearing the collar. This will happen over time and there really is no better bonding for you and your dog than good, respectful training.

If you are struggling with the training of your beloved pet, Doggy Dan wants to help! This course is effective, and easy to do with just six minutes a night! 

Click Here to get your $1 Doggy Dan trial today!


My name is Nina, and I'm crazy about animals. I've spent years looking after my dogs, and have gained tons of tips. I decided to start writing about the best products that I came across, and that's how Dogs By Nina began.